NFL Awards Odds: Betting Guide for 2024/25 Season

Written by: Christian Holmes Fact checked by: Jaclyn Hurst

The 2024-25 NFL season is finally here, and the chance to look through all the NFL Awards odds to find the best bet is more salivating than ever. For example, you might not like the Buffalo Bills’ chances of winning the Super Bowl, but Josh Allen to win the NFL MVP Award seems much more likely. Not to mention, the price you’d be getting on Allen could best be described as “sizzling,” as everyone is backing Patrick Mahomes of the Kansas City Chiefs to bring home the NFL’s most prized individual award.

If this sounds enticing to you at all, stick around. We’re going to give you some insights into the current NFL award odds so you can make your picks at the best NFL sportsbooks.

NFL MVP Odds 2024-25

Here are the latest NFL MVP odds, courtesy of BetVictor:

Holmesy’s Betting Pick: NFL MVP Odds

When I wrote my AFC North betting preview article, I was quite bullish on the Cincinnati Bengals. I had so much faith in Cincinnati because the team had Joe Burrow playing quarterback. He’s finally healthy. Burrow’s offensive line seems to have gotten better in the offseason, and the Bengals’ defence is above average, so realistically, it wouldn’t be crazy to see Cincy go on a bit of a run. Don’t get me wrong, after the team’s Week 1 loss to the New England Patriots, I’m not feeling overly bullish. That said, I still believe in what I wrote. As such, I’d be very interested in backing Joe Burrow’s +900 NFL MVP odds. I have this line priced closer to +600, so there’s some value there for the taking.

Another name in the NFL MVP betting odds I’ve been gravitating towards is CJ Stroud of the Houston Texans. The Texans will live and die with how well Stroud does. Yes, the defence looks to have gotten better, but it’ll be up to Stroud to put points on the board. In his rookie year, Stroud did much of the “little things” right and made those around him better by doing so. Heck, the Texans made it to the AFC Divisional Round. If Stroud takes that “next step” in 2024, +1100 odds for him to win the NFL MVP award will seem generous.

Of course, you can’t have this conversation without acknowledging Patrick Mahomes of the Kansas City Chiefs. By all means, Mahomes’ has more offensive weapons than Russia has nuclear bombs, so, in theory, as long as Mahomes plays to his averages, he should take home the NFL MVP trophy. That said, we’re not digging the price, especially with so many other enticing options.

NFL Offensive Player of the Year Odds 2024-25

Here are the latest NFL OPOY odds courtesy of BetVictor:

Holmesy’s Betting Pick: NFL Offensive Player Odds

Honestly, this is Tyreek Hill’s award to win. After what happened during Week 1, he was a big reason why the Dolphins were able to come back to beat the Jags. Hill recorded 130 receiving yards in the game, capped off with an 80-yard touchdown reception and an unforgettable touchdown celebration. As Miami’s offence will be “pass first,” even with a backup quarterback taking over Tua’s duties, Hill will get plenty of targets. This means he’ll get a fair number of chances to pick up yards and get touchdowns. We’re not loving the +700 price. That said, one more good game and Hill’s odds will only get shorter.

The only other name we would consider is Saquon Barkley of the Philadelphia Eagles. Barkley’s situation in Philly is 10 times better than what he had playing for the New York Giants. He has a quarterback who knows how to throw the ball, which opens up running room for Barkley when the opposing defences try to stop the pass. If Barkley can stay healthy, you’re not buying into a bad price by taking him at +2,000 odds. That’s probably the best value in the NFL Offensive Player of The Year odds.

NFL Defensive Player of the Year Odds 2024-25

Here are the latest NFL DYOP odds, courtesy of BetVictor:

Holmesy’s Betting Pick: NFL Defensive Player Odds

When I looked at the NFL DYOP odds, one player that I believe is totally undervalued is Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker T.J. Watt. Watt is hands down the heart and soul of Pittsburgh’s defence. He’s almost always a lock to get a sack, and offensive linemen can’t stop him if their lives depended on it. Getting +850 odds on him feels like a steal. Watt will be in every DPOY conversation as long as he stays healthy. As such, Watt will probably get bet down to +500, making +850 a great buy low, sell high spot.

Aiden Hutchinson of the Detroit Lions isn’t a bad player to take a shot on if you’d prefer a longer price. He does seem to be the backbone of the Lions’ defence. If Detroit makes it to the postseason, it’ll be because of his efforts. +1400 feels like a good number to roll the dice on, especially if you’re a fan of the Lions or the Michigan Wolverines (where Hutchison played his college ball).

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year Odds 2024-25

Here are the latest NFL OROY odds, courtesy of BetVictor:

Holmesy’s Betting Pick: NFL Offensive Rookie Odds

Honestly, this is Caleb Williams’ award to lose this year. Look, he didn’t come out too hot in Week 1 against the Tennessee Titans, BUT he didn’t totally embarrass himself, either. Give him a couple of games to get settled, and you should see him start to excel. Yes, the +120 odds are short. That said, we’d expect to see books list him to -125 once Williams strings together some good games. He has a good group of receivers, a decent O-line, a good head coach and an offensive coordinator. He has the tools to succeed. Williams just needs to learn how to utilize them.

If we were to look elsewhere, we’d back Marvin Harrison Jr. of the Arizona Cardinals. If his quarterback, Kyler Murray, can get his stuff together and learn to utilize Harrison’s skills, MHJ’s stock will rise. +650 will seem like a steal.

NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year Odds 2024-25

Here are the latest NFL DROY odds, courtesy of BetVictor:

Holmesy’s Betting Pick: NFL Defensive Rookie Odds

If you like a challenge, picking through the NFL Defensive Rookie of The Year odds to find a winner will keep you busy. I, myself, am still perplexed. There are so many good options to choose from, which is why I have a hard time siding with Dallas Turner of the Dallas Cowboys. The kid has gotten a lot of love from experts in the industry. I’m just not sold on him as much as I am on Laiatu Latu, the new DE for the Indy Colts. With the scheme the Colts play, Latu should be able to record a good chunk of tackles and make some game-changing plays. +400 odds feel short, but if Latu does have a good start to his season, the odds will probably get shorter. We’ll take our chances with him here in this spot.

NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds 2024-25

Here are the latest NFL CPOY odds, courtesy of BetVictor:

Holmesy’s Betting Pick: NFL Comeback Player Odds

Everybody on God’s green earth has been betting on Aaron Rodgers to win Comeback Player of The Year. That said, if you look through the NFL Comeback Player of The Year odds, a player is being offered at a much better price who I believe has a much greater chance than Rodgers to win the CPOY.

That player is none other than Anthony Richardson of the Indianapolis Colts. As I said in the Week 1 edition of Holmesy’s Fighting Words, Richardson is legit. His mechanics are solid. He can read the secondary better than most young QBs in the NFL. Not to mention, Richardson can run faster than Wiley Coyote if need be. When he runs, he’s elusive. All Richardson has to do is keep himself healthy. If he can do that, +650 will be the biggest gift of the year from the sportsbooks to the bettors.

Nobody else on this list really impresses me. A-Aron Rodgers probably wins this award if he has a half-decent season because most award voters like to lick his boots. That said, if Burrow picks up the MVP, the CPOY award probably goes to someone else, so we’re leaving Burrow out of this conversation. Quite frankly, he’s destined for bigger things.

NFL Coach of the Year Odds

Here are the latest NFL COTY odds, courtesy of BetVictor:

Holmesy’s Betting Pick: NFL Coach of the Year Odds

The absolute disrespect shown towards Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin is unbelievable. If there was ever a dark horse to win Coach of the Year, it’s Coach Tomlin. I have somewhat high expectations for the Steelers this season, so take everything I’m saying with a grain of salt.

The Steelers’ defence is off the charts, and Tomlin always puts together a good scheme with his DC. Although the offence is a work in progress, Coach Tomlin will bring the best out of his players, especially those in the quarterback position. By the end of the year, Justin Fields will go from being a draft bust to an above-average NFL-worthy QB who can use his athleticism to change games on a whim. Coach Tomlin will be the main reason he succeeds if that’s the case. If the Steelers make it to the playoffs and make a bit of a run, +1400 odds on Coach Tomlin seem outright foolish.

Lock it in, baby. No one else in the NFL Coach of The Year odds meets our fancy. It’s Coach Tomlin or bust.

NFL Super Bowl Odds 2025

Head on over to our dedicated, in-depth guide to all-things Super Bowl odds here. We’ve got you covered, showing you all the X’s and O’s, not to mention where you can get the best Super Bowl odds in Canada.

NFL Awards Betting Odds: Tips and Strategies

One of the best things you can do when betting on NFL Awards odds is to figure out how certain markets are going to behave and anchor your betting strategies around that. For example, right after the NFL draft, you would’ve gotten quite a short price on Caleb Williams because many viewed him as the only OROY candidate. It was him and the field. At that point, if you really liked him, you were better off waiting for Williams to have a bad week. What do you know? You got that right away after Williams had a “meh” rookie debut. It wasn’t the end of the world, but since people are reacting that way, the books can give him out at +120 and not worry too much. The moment he has a good game, that price will go back into the -125 range.

Now, it makes the most sense to bet a player early when you’re getting good odds on them because the books are favouring other notable players. For example, it would’ve made sense to grab T.J. Watt before the season when you can get him around +850 to +900 odds. If Watt goes ham and Micah Parsons has a few bad games, Watt’s price is bound to get shorter. That means you’ll lose your edge.

Summing It Up: Your Guide to NFL Awards Odds

Wagering on any type of futures bet can be tiresome, especially with the odds changing as the season progresses. Some players who you liked to win certain awards easily, end up crapping the bed. Whereas, some players you thought were bums come out and play like they’re five-star recruits. Nevertheless, if you know what you’re looking for, you can make some money with your NFL awards predictions. The key to finding success will always be gambling responsibly and waiting for the right spot to get in on +EV plays.

NFL Awards Odds FAQs